Albany, NY. Temple Beth Emeth sanctuary. Percival Goodman, architect, 1953-57. Photo: Samuel D. Gruber 2007.
Springfield, MA. Temple Beth El sanctuary (1968 rebuilding), present view. Percival Goodman, architect. Photo: courtesy TBE
Happy Birthday Percival Goodman (1904-1989)!
by Samuel D. Gruber
I first wrote about the synagogue architecture of Percival Goodman more than a decade ago, but only recently realized we share a birthday. Here are some observations about Goodman's life and work adapted from a much longer keynote presentation given at Temple Beth El,
Springfield, MA , on October 27, 2013 as part of a symposium on Goodman, Beth El and modern synagogue design.
Although I've visited about a dozen of Goodman's synagogues - including some of his best - there are dozens more I know only from drawings and photos. Fortunately, Goodman's synagogues have worn well and most continue in use today - often more than a half century after their design and construction - so I'll probably still get to see them in my travels.
Percival Goodman, who died
in 1989, is one of the least-known best American architects of the 20th
century. He was a technical master in design and
drawing, and a visionary and seeker in his quest for knowledge and
understanding of the built world and human condition. Goodman taught a generation of post-World War
II architects at Columbia University from 1946 to 1971, and even while he was
strong advocate of modern design, he also championed a more humane city and
search for architectural and urban form to best serve the most people.
Percival Goodman as a young art student. Photo from Elman,
and Giral, Angela, eds, Percival Goodman: architect,
planner, teacher, painter (NY: Columbia
University, 2001).
Percival Goodman designing. Photo from Elman,
and Giral, Angela, eds, Percival Goodman: architect,
planner, teacher, painter (NY: Columbia
University, 2001).
In his lifetime,
Goodman became the most prolific synagogue designer in history (though the commissions of more recent architects such as the Levin Brown have
surpassed him in number, but not in originality). But there is some irony in the fact that
many, perhaps most, of Goodman’s synagogues were erected in the post-war
suburbs that were antithetical to much of his thinking about community and
society. Goodman himself sounded less
than happy with his fate as master synagogue architect (as opposed to master
architect) when in 1957 he described – only in part tongue-in-cheek – the
“essential” aspects of modern synagogue design – the program that every
architect needed to contend with:
“It is an auditorium
used for a certain kind of spectacle or pageant. The congregant is spectator
more than participant as is indicated by the proscenium theater type of seating
and platform. The seating is divided by
a center aisle and broad steps lead to the platform, these being primarily
required for weddings and funerals. As the congregation is passive, the musical
parts of the service depend on paid choristers; a concealed choir is the
general rule. ..at the platform the Ark is central, over it an electric fixture
of special design. This will be flanked by prominently located chairs for the
officiants. There will be sometimes one,
sometimes two lecterns for preaching and reading…The hall is well lit for each
follows what he can of the service in his prayer book. Good acoustics for the spoken voice are essential
as the sermon is generally the main feature of the service. A public address system is always provided to
avoid undue strain on the speaker and guarantee an easy presentation…we need
air-conditioning and elaborate temperature controls. Similarly, foam rubber cushioning on seats is
required. There are other requirements
which, though minor, are indicative. These center around the effortless and, so
to speak, professional quality of the service…The essence of the mechanical
refinements is to create a service which moves with the smoothness of a
television program." [Myron
Shoen and Eugene Lipman, eds., Proceedings
of the Second National Conference and Exhibition on Synagogue Architecture and
Art (New York: Union of American Hebrew Congregations, 1958)].
Goodman strove to
overcome the inherent restrictions in the mid-century program, sometimes with
more success; sometimes with less. He was not one to create the same design twice.
Springfield, MA. Temple Beth El. 1953 building, Percival Goodman architect.
Springfield, MA. Temple Beth El. 1953 building, Percival Goodman architect.
His biography shows an
ambitious boy and then a man, intent on betterment, and attuned to the tastes
and needs of his time. He had an easy childhood until the age of seven, then
his world turned topsy-turvy when his wealthy father abandoned the family and
left them destitute. Percy felt the fall
from grace hard. He set out to reinvent
himself, and in a certain sense to recover what was lost. At age 13, Percy began his architectural
training with a uncle (albeit, sweeping floors) and by age twenty-one, in 1925,
he had won America's most prestigious architectural prize, the Prix de Paris,
and was celebrated in the New York Times (in which he gilded his
upbringing – ignoring his troubles).
Goodman’s
early independence - he was already paying his rooming house fees from his
wages at age thirteen – instilled in him a drive and work ethic, and quest for
experience and knowledge, that continued
throughout his life. In the trajectory of Goodman's
work in the 1920s and 1930s – from the design of functional tenements and
offices to more elaborate Beaux-Arts design, to modernism, we can see the rapid
developments in American architectural practice and taste. But the Great Depression stalled and then
stopped his architectural rise, and during World War II, when he was designing
camouflage for factories and trains it seemed his architectural career was
over.
Goodman did many things very
well, and was an inspirational teacher
and mentor. After the war was able to reinvent himself, in part through
writing, with his younger
brother the New Left philosopher Paul Goodman, with whom he published Communitas
in 1947; and through teaching, first at NYU in 1945, and then at Columbia,
where he continued to teach three afternoons a week until 1971.
It was in these years – the 1940s - that Goodman also was drawn to Judaism, the
religion into which he had been born but had had little training and for which
he previously had little use. The trauma
of the Holocaust affected him personally, while aesthetic and architectural
possibilities within American Judaism attracted him professionally. Goodman already was familiar with Jewish
clients – first those of his uncle, Benjamin Levitan, in whose office he had
first worked a boy and then his own many Jewish clients when he was engaged in
commercial and residential architecture in the 1920s and 30s. In 1948, however, Goodman received his first
commission for a synagogue, and in 1949 he was also working on a design for a Holocaust monument for
Riverside Park, and engaged to adapt the former Warburg Mansion into New York’s
Jewish Museum.
Goodman
knew that it takes more than a building to animate Judaism. It really works the other way around. Goodman recalled the dedication of one of his
synagogues in Cleveland: “Rabbi Brickner, the rabbi of the congregation, and I
were looking at the sanctuary and he said “What’s missing from this place?” And
I looked around and I said, Well what’s missing from this place, is the
Shekinah – is God’s presence.” The
awareness of his only religious doubts, and his simultaneous recognition of the
possibilities of religion was what made Goodman the most articulate and visible
proponent of a new type and style of synagogue for post-War era.
It was in part his interest in
expressing community through architectural language, and his reaction to the
Holocaust, that led Goodman to synagogue design. He famously said the he was “an agnostic who
was converted by Hitler.” But a series of fortuitous events helped his
progress. In June 1947, the Union of
American Hebrew Congregations sponsored a two-day symposium in New York City to
address the increasingly pressing needs for new synagogue construction in the
post-war period. Few synagogues had been
built since the onset of the Great Depression, and the pent up demand for new
synagogues, especially in new suburban neighborhoods rising to serve returning
GIs and their new families, offered a challenge and an opportunity. Changing demographics, coupled with new urban
policies (or perhaps I should say anti-urban policies ) were working against
reinvestment in older Jewish neighborhoods.
Increasingly, congregational leaders as well young families were
settling in new areas, and it wasn’t long before the leaders persuaded their
congregations to follow suit.

Providence, R.I.. Temple Beth El..Percival Goodman, architect, 1948-55. Photo: Samuel D. Gruber 2005
Providence, R.I.. Temple Beth El, sanctuary..Percival Goodman, architect,1948-55. Photo:Paul Rocheleau 2002
Providence, R.I.. Temple Beth El, chapel. Percival Goodman, architect, 1948-55. Photo:Paul Rocheleau 2002
“An American Synagogue for Today and Tomorrow”
provided a forum for architects, artists, rabbis, and officials of Reform
Judaism to share ideas for what a modern synagogue should look like, how it
should function, and what resources were available for its construction. The symposium followed an article in Commentary Magazine by architectural
historian Rachel Wischnitzer, “The Problem of Synagogue Architecture.” Goodman, along with art historian Franz
Landsberger of Hebrew Union College, and architects Erich Mendelsohn and Eli Jacques Kahn (not to be confused with
other leading architects of the same name – Albert Kahn and Louis Kahn) were
invited to respond.
Goodman addressed the New York
symposium on the topic “The Holiness of Beauty,” and made a great impression. His talk and subsequent interviews
led directly to at least three commissions – for Baltimore Hebrew Congregation;
Congregation B’nai Israel in Millburn, New Jersey; and Beth Israel in Lima,
Ohio. Shortly after, he was hired by
Rabbi William G. Braude to design a new synagogue for Temple Beth El of
Providence, Rhode Island, which settled on Goodman after a lengthy search and
consultation process.
Lima, Ohio.Temple Beth Israel. Percival Goodman, architect, 1948-9. Photo courtesy Beth Israel-Shaare Zedek, Etta Weintraub and Anne Handley via Julian Priesler
Millburn, NJ..B'nai Israel. Percival Goodman, architect, 1949-51. Photo:Samuel D. Gruber 2008.
Goodman had been recommended by, among others, German émigré Stephen Kayser, curator of New York’s Jewish
Museum, over Kayser's fellow émigrés Mendelsohn and Fritz Nathan. Goodman had recently renovated the Warburg
Mansion for the Jewish Museum, and this gave him architectural yiches. That project, working with Kayser, allowed
him to identify more as a Jew, and also to confront his own ignorance about the
basic tenets and history of his religion.
Art historian Meyer Schapiro, a medievalist who was a champion of New
York modern art, also recommended his Columbia University colleague
Goodman. Dynamic American-born, English speaking
Goodman was able to best promote modernist ideas in the American Jewish
community, and best embodied the new can-do post-War American Zeitgeist.
Though by 1950, Goodman was widely considered one
the America’s leading synagogue and Jewish architects, he never presented himself as
overtly religious in any sense. He said
“I don’t have any notion of what God is all about; I’m very suspicious of the
whole notion of God. Therefore I can
only deal with men. Well that’s not as
high an aspiration as God and therefore the work I do will always be secular.”
Goodman, because of his interest in community planning, was especially
interested in finding ways for synagogues built anew to embody community
values, and to inspire Jewish community life.
Goodman was ready, like so many after World War II, to distance himself
with passed – failed – solutions. He
said “But you have to ask why? Why was
it done in the first place? And then,
why do it now?”
Synagogues
needed to be noticeable, even striking and monumental. Because of his design experience, including
work for retail establishments, Goodman saw that architecture could be a
selling point for synagogues, too. Designs
were aimed at Jews – those in the congregation, but also unaffiliated
Jews. New buildings almost always
increased congregational membership – at least for a while. But design was also aimed at Christians –
formerly goyim, but now “gentiles”. Congregations wanted to make a good
impression, and to live up to their new status – talked about increasing since
the war years – as one of America’s three major religions.
Goodman said, “In one sense the
synagogue represents for the Jewish community a thing that they can show to
their Christian neighbors. In that sense
of the public relations gesture, I have been able to convince them that they
ought to use a good artist, not any old artist, because in the end the
Christian community will learn that this is the good artist…The Christian
community ultimately discovered that the artists that were employed to paint or
sculpt for the building, in fact, were well-known people…all very hot-stuff for
the Christian ladies’ clubs. And in a
sense it’s been a very good propaganda device for the conversion of the heathen
to modern art.”
Beginning
in1949 and for more than two decades Goodman played a leading role in guiding
the Architects Advisory Panel of the Union of Hebrew Congregations. The panel offered free services of architects
on a consulting basis to congregations that needed help planning their
projects. Free consulting could, of
course, lead to paid commissions. The
effects in synagogue design change were felt across all branches of American
Judaism, and Goodman designed many synagogues for Conservative congregations. In the early 1950s
simple straight-forward modernism was a form of architectural branding – and
was as fresh as congregations hoped that their appeal to Jews would be. Subsequently the simple style became boring,
and be the late 1950s more and more congregations and their architects –
including Goodman – were adding some dramatic accents to their designs.
Southfield, MI. Congregation Shaarey Zedek.Percival Goodman, architect. Photo:Samuel D. Gruber 2007
Southfield, MI. Congregation Shaarey Zedek.Percival Goodman, architect. Photo:Samuel D. Gruber 2007